The best I've found for sensitive skin is here:

Shaving Brushes for Men's Wet Shaving, Razor and Shaving Brush Kits, Em's Supplies

Go into her online catalog, and look for aftershaves. You'll be looking for the aftershave and moisture balm. It comes in three sizes.

I like the bay rum. If you've had a bad shave, this stuff is like facial morphine; I'm serious. I've never had anything relieve the burn and irritation better than this.

Don