I'll try to make this easy and list my likes/dislikes.
I'm looking for something unique, meaning there are not many scents similar.

My favorites:
Alt Innsbruck (very unique, hands down my favorite AS)
4711 (unique, wonderful scent)
Proraso (great stuff)

Likes:
St. Lucia Bay Rum (best bay rum, IMO)
Thayers (good stuff, but not scented)

Dislikes:
Pinaud in any form
Old Spice
Brut
English Leather
Aqua Velva

I thought about picking up Floid, but it sounds like something I wouldn't like--the "powder scent" people mention is offputting.
I'm not big on floral scents or anything that smells like a doctors office.

Alt Innsbruck is probably the most unique AS i've used and so is 4711, both are night and day from each other, but work/smell great.
There are so many AS splashes and I don't want to buy something that I'll never use. Typically, people have similar tastes, so if you love 4711, Proraso and Alt Innsbruck than offer me a suggestion.

Also, this is splashes, not balms. I have balms/lotions and don't see myself changing from Proraso liquid cream or Pre de Provence--I've used others and they don't stack up.

I'd like at least one more AS splash to use...
Thanks.