Thread: My Collection - Identifying, Valuing, and Restoring

That's cool I guess. Not exactly looking to sell them really. I was more of asking if I gave any of them new scales, would I be destroying their collectible value? Or rather, if any were collectible or rare enough to even worry about such a thing?

I don't want to modify one and find out later that I made a huge mistake.

Originally Posted by Crowcaine

That's cool I guess. Not exactly looking to sell them really. I was more of asking if I gave any of them new scales, would I be destroying their collectible value? Or rather, if any were collectible or rare enough to even worry about such a thing?

I don't want to modify one and find out later that I made a huge mistake.

I do not think the collectible value will be lost upon replacing the scales, but that is me.

Right. I always made the assumption that the blade is what truly mattered, given that the most popular choice of material for the scales is "hey, what's the cheapest plastic we can find to put on these?"

*EDIT* And if anyone knows of anyone in Pittsburgh that deals in restorations or really any general traditional shaving sales and knowledge, I would love to be pointed in the right direction. There are many things I'd love to ask and witness first hand.

Originally Posted by Crowcaine

Right. I always made the assumption that the blade is what truly mattered, given that the most popular choice of material for the scales is "hey, what's the cheapest plastic we can find to put on these?"

I think you'll find both viewponts on that subject depending on who you ask
To me, original scales is more or less a must.
I loose most any interest I might have had when I see modern materials or design in a new set of scales on a vintage razor.
Sure, if the original scales are defect in some way, a new set of scales will be the better option.
If the original is beyond repair that is.

Contact one of the resto guys in the link provided previously, they will give you a better idea than our guesswork.
You could always get one or two done and store the rest for now.

On old straight razors I like to keep the original scales on them if possible. If they're junk, I'll try to find another old set that fit.
Magpie is right on about the horn scales. I bet they will clean up just gorgeous as long as they aren't cracked or damaged in any way. I love working with horn even though it does stink. The outcome is well worth the effort. Follow his advice, you won't go wrong!

Never forget, in the world of craftsmanship, "Ya Gets What Cha Pays For"

There are also "levels" of restoration. Myself, I am usually happy with a simple clean and polish. I like to do the best job possible without removing the blades for a full on resto.
If you are ok with a basic resto, send me a PM. If you want full pins off mirror polish, and you don't want to wait for Brad, send a note to Gssixgun (pretty much the resident resto guru/go to honemiester guy)