I think its not that Lynn put a bad edge on it. Lets say hypothetically that you had perfect technique. Maybe both blades are sharper than your threshold for distinguishing- I certainly can't tell the difference between sharp level 49 and sharp level 50 lol.

On the other hand, maybe the guy who honed your razor was good too. There are a lot of unsung heroes () on this forum who can put a wicked edge on the blade, they just aren't honemeisters.