Thread: Solingen Vs. Sheffield

Thanks for everyone's comments. I don't have as much honing experience as all of you, so I cannot comment on the difficulting to make shave ready. I was strictly going on shave quality. And by that, I also mean condition of my skin following the shave.

I also thought it might be individual razors as opposed to location of production or manufacturer. So back to rotating through the stock and taking notes.

David

Here are my thoughts, but I really want to emphasize that YMMV (that's why I put it in bold )

In terms of looks, I love the sheffield style. Big chunks of steel with wicked smiles and barber's notches. They seem to have a medieval elegance to them, and they give me great shaves. I love the variations and the aesthetics of those old sheffield blades.

On the other hand, the german (and most american vintage razors) generally seem pretty vanilla to me in terms of looks, but man -oh man do those blades perform! I would have to give solingen blades an advantage in terms of performance ----YMMV---- over sheffields. they seem to take wicked edges, and the full hollows get downright nasty sharp. After some time, I have come to agree with those who believe that they get the closest shaves (with the least work) from full hollows.

Now, I hate to add a wrinkle to your question, but if you pressed me on the issue I might say that I prefer swedish razors over both solingen AND sheffield razors And I have a few american razors that are on the tippy top of my list as well.

When I think of Sheffields, I think of wedges, some with a slight hollow, but generally quarter hollow, which is more wedge than not. There are exceptions and some are full hollows, but in my experience the majority of Sheffields are wedge type.

Solingen blades however, are mostly hollow ground towards the full type. Again there are exceptions, for example I have a 9/16 Schulze Stosse which is a quarter hollow, but most in my experience are full hollows.

So as a very broad suggestion to your very broad question, you are in a way comparing wedges to hollows, which I believe is part of one of the reasons as to why an earlier response agreed that some Sheffields are harder to hone.

Having owned many of both I personally think both are great, but there are few like for like comparisons in terms of grind and size. +1 on Solingen blades being more consistent in quality.

Joseph Rodgers are extremely high quality, and I find the shaves and workmanship to be very consistent. I love Wade and Butchers but can not agree their quality is as consistent.

By the way YMMV

[QUOTE=Scipio;586719]When I think of Sheffields, I think of wedges, some with a slight hollow, but generally quarter hollow, which is more wedge than not. There are exceptions and some are full hollows, but in my experience the majority of Sheffields are wedge type.

I own two Sheffields that are mine, in my rotation, one is a full hollow Bengal the other is a W&B Special full hollow... I don't like the way heavy blades feel...

Solingen blades however, are mostly hollow ground towards the full type. Again there are exceptions, but most in my experience are full hollows.

So as a very broad suggestion to your very broad question, you are in a way comparing wedges to hollows, which I believe is part of one of the reasons as to why an earlier response agreed that some Sheffields are harder to hone.


I am obviously +1'n here I think this is dead on...[/QUOTE]

Just between the two choices of steel and comparing apples to apples, of the full hollow grinds, in the size and type that I like personally, I would give the "Smooth" point to the Solingen razors... Barely !!!!! I find NO difference in the ease or difficulty of honing when comparing the same type of razor...

I've been honing for a couple of years now and am still learning. When I shave with a razor I honed early on it has a different feel than my more recently honed razors. When I go back and 'touch up' the razor with some of my more current learnings it falls into my current acceptance zone and changes my perception of the razor. So, just because a razor is honed and can shave hair doesn't mean it is honed up to it fullest potential. Like I said, I'm still learning and probably will till the day I die or go senile.

I'm not sure if it is what I'm used to, or if there really is a difference. My first blades were Duble Duck, Henckles and Union Cutlery. The first 2 being solingen, the third being US, and all three being full hollow. all were professionally honed. I recently added 2 W&Bs, one was a 9/16 barbers notch, the other a big chunk of 3/4+" steel with a very shallow hollow. They were honed by the same people who did the full hollow blades, but did not shave as close. I'm chalking it up to being "different" and expect to improve as I learn them.

BTW, my 3 favorite shavers are US made. A Torrey and 2 Unions.

Goog

I like both, but agree that almost all the Solingen made blades are full hollow. There are exceptions, and I own, or have owned, full hollow Sheffield and quarter hollow Solingen razors, but as a general statement many Sheffield razors are quarter hollow, many Solingen blades are full hollow.

Now it is also a general opinion of many senior members that a full hollow razor simply requires shaving technique that reflects experience. I have found this to be the case myself.

So, what you may prefer are quarter to half hollow razors which happen to be made mostly, but not exclusively, in Sheffield, not necessarily Solingen vs. Sheffield.

Originally Posted by Joed

I've been honing for a couple of years now and am still learning. When I shave with a razor I honed early on it has a different feel than my more recently honed razors. When I go back and 'touch up' the razor with some of my more current learnings it falls into my current acceptance zone and changes my perception of the razor. So, just because a razor is honed and can shave hair doesn't mean it is honed up to it fullest potential. Like I said, I'm still learning and probably will till the day I die or go senile.

Hey Joe -- you can still learn stuff when you're senile....sometimes the same stuff over and over and over. It's new every day! Sometimes every hour! Trust me, I'm daft already.