Thread: What about -- a condition rating system?

I was thinkin' -- I know that because I'm still nauseous -- has anyone else thought about a condition rating system for vintage straights? Maybe a sub-forum where vintage razors could be graded --by condition, not value -- and some standards considered and applied. It might help the uninitiated in their shopping, and be a topic of some discussion.

I'll go back in my hole now.

Condition is so subjective... at least to the owner.

The old "If it's mine, it's stuff; you own crap" syndrome.

I think it is " buyer beware" or something like that...............JR

What I would like to see is something along the NRA rating system used for guns. The item would start at NIB 100% and then work its way down the scale, subtracting percentage points for individual flaws. It would still be somewhat subjective between the eyes of the beholder(s), but I think it would work.

If i am not mistaken it has been done long time ago for our classified sale.
Lets say if i am selling razor and it is condition fair and i put excellent?
i cannot do so.
where it is i am not sure but i know it should be somewhere in SRP.

Originally Posted by nun2sharp

What I would like to see is something along the NRA rating system used for guns. The item would start at NIB 100% and then work its way down the scale, subtracting percentage points for individual flaws. It would still be somewhat subjective between the eyes of the beholder(s), but I think it would work.

Or add points for correcting individual flaws

I've seen it talked about several times. It's not a bad idea, but as mentioned opinion is subjective. I think most sellers on here will be either on the money or actually downplay their blade they are selling so that the buyer will be pleased.

I could be wrong, but I hope & think that I am not...

Either a razor is Near NOS or a restorers dream....

I just tell people don't expect much and you won't be disappointed.

This might be useful: Mint