Search:

I don't think it's the pen. I have even used a brass made key for the job. And, it works :p .
It's a mystery. It's improbable that both of the stones are defective, and the possible embedded...

Some stone manufacturers actually don't recommend using sandpaper for flattening their stones.Also, are you honing under running water? It might help. From what I see, it must be the stones.