Search:

Well, I use both.
I use the toner more in the winter, when I'm more prone to dry skin. In the summer I use the astringent, and alcohol-based lotions, more.

Did you have problems with breaking...

Hey there, brlaskowski. Welcome to Straight Razor Place!
My recomendation would be Thayer's Witch Hazel. It comes as a non-alcohol toner, or as an asteingent with alcohol.