Shay,

Glad to hear it.

If the toe is dull, there's a chance it wasn't getting stropped as much as the rest of the blade. You have to keep your strokes slow and very even. (Or it could have been duller to start out...)

If you can live with it, you might want to let it go for the time being. You'll probably want to do another touch up in five or six shaves anyway, and you can try to fix it then.

It's possible to go too far with the pastes, which will make the edge worse. Maybe do another 1-5 or two... More than that and I think we'd be getting into risky territory.

Good luck,
Josh