Actually, I gave the responder a link to the history of ingredients listed on boxes over the years:
Look at the "Ingredients Timeline" http://wiki.badgerandblade.com/Williams.
I have tried the pre-Combe Williams Mug Soap and it lathers easily. The current formulation is much harder to lather and does not perform as well. I'd become a permanent Williams customer if you changed back to the earlier formulations.