I have most of those soaps plus many more and just thought I would try something new. I also read many reviews about Sundance Soapery before giving it a shot. Even watched a YouTube video which gave them a great review. I guess I was initially intrigued by the goat's milk ingredient as well as many other natural ingredients that went into their products. Her website is also very professional looking as well which made me think that I may be on to something great. The two soap pucks that I purchased were relatively cheap at around $2.50 a piece plus $4.50 shipping so I didn't really break the bank or anything. I was just seriously disappointed in the quality of the soaps. Virtually no lather whatsoever. Just dry filmy bubbles that quickly popped and dissipated. I didn't even bother to shave with the pucks because I knew I'd be in for some serious burn and cuts. Figured I'd get the word out before other folks wasted their time and money. She promised to send another batch but never did. Her reply:

Hello
I'm sorry you didn't like the shaving soap. I can send out a different recipe next week when I get back. Some people really like it, but you have to get used to the all natural with no lathering agents in it.
Thanks so much Deena

My main questions:
No lathering agents? Why would anyone want to shave without a lather?