Thread: Mitchell's Wool Fat (MWF)

Presentation: Brililant! Came in a nice brown carton box. Inside the bowl was further wrapped in nylon, possibly to preserve freshness and scent. Then the gorgeous, heavy porcelain bowl. It is definitely a nice addition to the bathroom. Very retro.

I would have liked the bowl to be smaller, or the puck bigger, to fit tightly like the Tabac does or many others. Figure the soap will be wobbling around inside a lot. But I wet underneath the puck and so far it stuck, wouldn't move while brushing on top of it. Nice!

Scent: Intoxicating. I look forward to using all my soaps, but this is the one that gets me into the bathroom with the biggest smile on my face. It's a faint, never over-bearing scent. But while some say it's very soapy or natural, I am thinking perfume. It's quite good.

Lather-ability: Oh boy! Maybe I should get my eyes checked, or perhaps I live in a parallel universe. What's with the lathering controversy? London hard water, a normal badger brush, a few swirls on the puck and lather! Is it possible that there are old(er) pucks and new(er) productions and that it changes/hardens over time? I do NOT see an issue at all. It is just like my Tabac or Proraso, true not like a shaving cream that just produces explosions of lather, but it's great!

Okay, it is a bit thirsty. And dries out a little fast. But just keep adding droplets of water and all is well.

Performance: I found it to be quite protective from the blade. Gives good cushion and you can adjust the consistency with water.

I have never shaved and had my skin so soft and face supple afterward. I thought maybe it was a new AS I got recently, so I tried it with different combinations of blades and AS. It's amazing, no razor burn, no red skin, I'm not even getting irritation from my shirt collars as I usually do.

Conclusion: If you haven't tried it yet, BUY IT NOW!

Agreed.

While this soap took awhile to grow on me, after using it the last several times I've really grown to appreciate what a stellar soap in fact it is. Took a couple of months, never had any problem lathering it, but it just never really lived up, as far as I'm concerned, to all the hype.

After using it for two shaves recently, I came to realize what a great soap it is, and how it left my face feeling great - love that lanolin!

Thanks for the review and insights!

Could not agree more with your thoughts on MWF. I never found it hard to lather, it is hard to add too much water to it as it just loves water and few other soaps leave my face felling as nice. Yea, great soap, glad it worked so well for you.

Bob

Well I guess I'll have to try some !

I would love to try this soap, but have had a bad go of overbearing scents lately. I'm more of a MDC Fougere level of scent or not much more than that. So can someone describe the scent? or compare the scent maybe to another soap they've used?

I've heard Mikes Natural soaps compared to MWF once (performance), would this be a true?

No idea how to describe MWF scent other than to say I hardly notice it and it less pungent than MdC regular scented to me. Not strong at all to me.

Bob

Thank you for the detailed review! Now I want to try MWF too.

Originally Posted by Trimmy72

I would love to try this soap, but have had a bad go of overbearing scents lately. I'm more of a MDC Fougere level of scent or not much more than that. So can someone describe the scent? or compare the scent maybe to another soap they've used?

I've heard Mikes Natural soaps compared to MWF once (performance), would this be a true?

It's very faint, to the extent that by mid-shave I stop sensing it and try to lather more under my nose to bring it back.

I personally like the smell. It's clean, soapy.. I want to say like Johnson & Johnson baby shampoo but that wouldn't be accurate. Maybe Prada Infusion would go along with it.

Thanks for the review, sums up my thoughts as well

Now, if you want your face to feel EXTRA soft shave with MWF and then splash on some Musgo Real aftershave. One of my all time favourite combos

As I've said before what's not to like. Great review very fair.

As an aside when we lived in a village near Buxton in the Peak District one of the biggest sheep farmers in the UK had a farm just down the road. Bearing in mind he spent most of his days outside in all weathers he had the softness hands due to the lanolin in the sheep's coats which transferred on handling them to vaccinate or give them some other treatment.