Thread: Dr Harris comparison with MWF and Tabac

Tabac>Windsor>Arlington>Marlboro>MWF.

I have had and tried all the above. I find MWF finicky and uninspiring I much prefer Haslingers to MWF. As to Tabac...its Tabac...Stellar Nuf said. Of the Dr. Harris line I very much like Windsor and Arlington but Windsor is more "Manly" and my wife agrees. Marlboro is "ok" it is Woodsey and smells a bit (a lot actually) smoky. Many have compared it to an ashtray scent. I wouldn't go that far but it's definitely not a favorite of the three. As always your likes and mileage may vary.

Don't hate simply my opinion.

Last time I used them, I found my Tabac more finicky than MWF , buy I probably didn't load up enough.
I do like Marlborough a lot though. I smelled the cologne in a shop and bought the soap puck but was disappointed the scent was so faint. I will give Windsor a sniff next time on your recommendation.

I've used all three and just my 2 pennies but MWF is probably the least in your face with the Arlington right there with it, followed by Windsor, Marlborough (Can't handle Sandal wood scents), and the Tabac to me is so strong you will smell it through out the day (But it is probably the best shave soap IMO out of any of them). But you won't catch Tabac in my rotation or the Marlborough they are just too intense for me. I must be scent sensitive as they give me a heavy feeling as in I could go sleep all day/depressed kinda feeling. I would go for Windsor...