The Obie Memorial First Tier Soaps and Creams Thread.

[rawfox1]

I thought this thread was about sharing experiences about various soaps.
How come all of a sudden not liking a soap is "hate"? I have not seen you defend other soaps that are in the 3rd or basement categories, why this one?

I use the word hating and today's terminology about not liking it's fine for everybody to express their viewpoints I was just sharing that it is in excellent soap and most people do enjoy it I own over hundred soaps and this is an excellent one as well everybody is entitled to their opinion

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[mainaman]

I was just sharing that it is in excellent soap and most people do enjoy it
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

I do not know if you know most people that have used it, but since the talk went into generalizations, If you look at the several really big forums with combined close to 100k membership in the SOTD threads there is very little PAA presence. Surely that is not because no one has head of PAA.

[jgkeegan]

I was just sharing that it is in excellent soap and most people do enjoy it

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

Interesting. Most of what I have read is negative plus I see it for sale in BSTs often. We probably read in different places.

[tcrideshd]

i myself sent PAA soaps to the shower and for the dogs bath, not hating mind you as you referenced at Stefan, but I myself have tried well over 100 soaps and creams, this was not in the top tier and I have over the last year just done away with all of the soaps I don't consider top tier. life is too short, but I do agree you dont hear much about PAA soaps ,, their not liked as much as you perceive.

now if you like them then that is what matters, I have a hard time believing you find it the best soap you use unless you have never tried some of the top tiers ie. Castle Forbes, MDC, and a short list of others,,, some of the Artisans soap are strong second tier, but I haven't found one to be top tier for me, as mentioned Stirling has some good offerings, but I don't use them any more either,, life is too short, for mediocre,, now his bath soaps are another story ,,, its all I use now, so enjoy what you like, but step out and try some others too, I still sample every soap that has a great following, and some of my friends have sent me some stellar soaps. have CF and MDC left my shave den? NO. Tc

[Aerdvaark]

I, ten times....