Im fairly new to SR Shaving, about 60 shaves in. I've tried an number of soaps recommended here, namely: Wholly Kaw, Mitchell's Wool Fat, D.R Harris and now Castle Forbes. I couldn't seem to get a decent lather from MWF or D.R. Harris. Wholly Kaw was a delight however. Today I lathered with Castle Forbes , I don't understand why I should use any other product.. A couple of swirls in the puck and I produced a thick rich luxurious lather in the mug. I don't think I'll go back to fighting with Mitchells or DR Harris. maybe someone can enlighten me.