Ive got only one from WK and it was given to me because of the strong scent. I too dont smell much in life do to my work, but this soap did calm down in scent after awhile. The greasy/buttery feel it has is over the top so i agree with you Vic. But the after the shave skin feel is great. Conditioned and softened. I do enjoy WK soaps and keep wanting to get more, just havent done so. Like someone said, its got everything you want in a shave soap but more than needed.