Im in the same boat as Razorfield. I hated the glycerin soaps as i couldnt get good lather from them. Gave them up! Then someone sent me a couple samples of Mamabear soaps. My sniffer doesnt work well so i cant comment on scent, but the quality of the soap is a top tier IMO. I dont think you can go wrong with any of them. Maybe ask for some samples from her so you can find what you like. But what you get will be great lathering soaps so dont sweat it and buy. You made a good choice!