Quote Originally Posted by thebigspendur View Post
Despite any claims I doubt you would find any soap that is both an old brand and the same exact formula. Even old names are just that having been defunct and bought and again used. Of course many ingredients are simply not used anymore for a variety of reasons.

I would be skeptical of any claims. I'll bet Mitchell's has no relation to the original maker. You would have to compare the formula to determine how true it is to the original.
That not withstanding, Mitchell's Wool Fat is some good stuff.