Thread: Who makes a good Bay Rum puck?

Bay leaves, spices, Rum. Some here even make their own version of aftershave, using Rum as the base.

Captain Morgan's spiced rum, works real well.

The Try That Soap web site has a list of soaps with bay leaf in the scent.

https://trythatsoap.com/scent/39/

Some of the products qualify as hard pucks, but the list should be helpful.

+1 for Meissner Tremonia & Green Mountain

My favorite Bay Rum scent is Captain's Choice Bay Rum. I have a strong sensitivity to clove, so I have to avoid Bay Rums that have close (most do). Captain's Choice uses cinnamon rather than clove, so it works for me.
This product is a soft soap in a tub, so if your are insistent on a hard puck, it won't be suitable.

Try Krampert’s Finest. It is the only American Made Soap that I have in my rotation.

I said it before, and I'll say it again.

Originally Posted by JBHoren

I no longer buy shaving products -- what I own will surely "outlive" me; but I do own one Bay Rum shaving soap: QED Bay Rum. True, it is no longer in production, but if you can acquire a tub (or a portion thereof), do so.

Unpaid Testimonial: The West Indies Bay Company "St. John's Bay Rum" EDC and matching ASB put a great finish on a QED Bay Rum shave.

Originally Posted by thebigspendur

Well, if you want a Bay Rum Shave Soap that is an authentic adult scent, Meisner Tremonia is great stuff and it's a top notch performing soap. Just be aware it's no sweet smelling soap it's the real thing.

As I had never heard of a Meissner-Tremonina bay rum shaving soap or paste and as I do like their products very much, I went to their website to see what they might have added since I checked last.

Sadly, I found no trace of a bay rum (containing rum, bay leaves, spices) shaving soap or paste and it appears that it might have been a limited edition that I missed when it was introduced and that has since been discontinued.


B.

Aloha!

And here I am sitting on top of a mound of soaps that I'll probably never use in my lifetime, and now I'm ordering some Bay Rum. Go figure.

-Zip