I'd have to say I wouldn't be interested in a $75 puck of glycerin soap either, tea tree is a great suggestion and would be dirt cheap considering how inexpensive that EO is and how little is needed.

What about a Jasmine FO? The QED Wild Rose and Violetta both use Fragrance Oil and smell very nice while still providing a great shave..I have not had any bad reactions to any of QED FO soaps

Tobacco still sounds interesting too