For creams, anyway I'd vote for AOS rose followed by T&H. AOS rose is a bit pricy because it has real rose absolute in it. T&H is nice because it is a light scent and pretty close IMHO. Not "perfumy" like Trumper & Taylor, for instance.
You're on your own for soaps, though. I have the original QED from several years ago, and Tryphon rose, but that's a pretty limited exposure wrt rose soaps.

John P.