I have the GFT Rose Cream, GFT Rose Soap, QED Wild Rose Soap, and used up a tub of Taylor Rose Cream.

GFT Cream - this was far and away my favorite soap or cream for half a year and then I just lost interest. Not sure why - maybe my tastes changed as I bought more and more products. But it's very good and smells nice, but is over-dyed and the smell is very concocted.

GFT Soap - nice stuff. understated scent, slick lather. I don't love the cushioning but it's a great soap.

QED - NICE SCENT. And I love the QED performance. My favorite rose product so far.

Taylor Rose - understated nice scent. If I started over I'd get this and not the GFT Cream.