I have many soaps/creams in my rotation. Colleens, (TGQ) Mama Bear's, MWF, Vintage blades triple milled stuff, (which is great by the way) some Goat's milk soap from the Soap shed, Some old Williams, Tabac, etc...For creams, I have CF, T&H, Nancy Boy, Proraso, Tabac, etc...Needless to say I have a bunch. AT least a dozen in rotation, I'm probably forgetting a few...
The thing is, and I want to be fair here, Colleen's soap doesn't lather worth a darn for me. Now, I have no trouble with anything else, at all. I have good brushes, Silver tip badger. I know how to work a lather, etc...
I read so many good reviews about her soaps and most of the time you guys are right on with your reviews.

Now, to be fair, I purchased the sample pack of 5 soaps and 2 creams. The creams were good, but my hand starts to hurt from trying to work a lather on her soaps. What I eventually do is, Uber them, that is a shot of "Kiss my face" and a couple of drops of glycerin. As I said, I want to be fair. Should I purchase a larger puck and give it a shot? I mean, if it get's all these good reviews, there must be something to it, right. Maybe I got a bad batch. The fragrance is great, but lather leaves something to be desired, it's just flat. I even have a water softner, so it makes extra lather, sort of...Any advice or opinions would be greatly appreciated.
Rich