Haven't tried a couple of those, but I've used the last three quite a bit.

1. Tabac - Great performer, and it often serves as a reference point when comparing others. Everyone should try it.
2. Proraso/C.O. Bigelow - Get the Bigelow cream and the Proraso "Sensitive" version of the soap (white tub). Skip the regular Proraso soap, which is nothing special, imo.
3. VDH - Not terrible, but you can skip it without missing much.