There are several tallow soaps on the shelf in the den. I like them all but there are three stand out performers. MWF, Institut Karite, and Tabac in that order give me the closest most comfortable shaves. The first two are neck and neck and the Tabac isn't far behind.

If you have experience with these soaps can you suggest others which might match them?

I have tried Palmolive, Valobra, Speick, Arko, VDH, Williams, and even Ivory. They are all in my PIF stack or gone.

Scent preference leans towards clean soapy fragrance but I have become accustomed to Tabac and really like it.