Thread: Did I get a bad batch of C.O. Bigelow?

I've noticed it too...all three of the tubes I purchased a couple months ago have an 'off' scent....almost like the same thing just a little musty like it had gotten old. Still works exactly the same.

The same thing happened to me earlier this year. I got a large tube that had a really strong smell. I mentioned to the store employee next time and she said bring it back, no problem. I did and they let me exchange it for a new one. I opened every tube, and found one with a better scent. I think there are just differences from batch to batch. This was before the new formulation hit the shelves. I would definitely open a few tubes before buying.