So far I have tried 55 different shaving products (mostly creams), only 7 of them have been soaps. I really can't wait to order the SRD sampler next time I place an order with them.
However, currently my top soaps are:
1) LUSH - Halloween edition pumpkin spice. I melted down one of their soaps and it makes an excellent shave soap. They use rapeseed oil, which isn't tops but it works for me. The scent is just amazing! Why don't we see more people making seasonal scents like pumpkin spice in the shave world!
2) Edwin Jagger - Sea Buckthorn
3) Van Der Hagen - Scented (cheap and worked great for me when I first started out)
That's it, all the rest have sucked in one way or another. Can't stand MWF, will probably throw out the rest of the puck and reuse the mug it's in for something else.