Thread: Cream or Soap

I'm sure a lot of this boils down to personal preference, but as a complete Newbie I am interested to hear what you guys think - should I start out with soap or cream, which is better? Any particular brand suggested? I plan on getting a C&E $35 best badger brush and am looking into something to lather.

I don't think you can go wrong with Tabac Shave Soap or Honeybee Spa soap. I don't think you're going to get a unified answer on this one. Maybe you can whittle down your choices based on your skin type (sensitive or not) and your bank account.

I definitely have sensitive skin (and at this point, I should probably try pinch some pennies) Any suggestions?

I have slightly sensitive skin as well --- I like the Honeybee Spa soaps. You can get them here:
http://stores.ebay.com/Honeybee-Spa-...QQftidZ2QQtZkm

I think Tabac Shave soap is pretty good. You can get the soap refill for about $10 at amazon.com.

People say the Provence Sante is the best for sensitive skin. About $10 for refill. You can buy both the Tabac and Provence Sante with container or just the refill. Add about $10 for the container.

On the cheap side, people say the Erasmic line is good.

As far as the creams --- I don't have much experience but there are a slew of good ones. People give thumbs up to the Taylors Avocado for sensitive skin.

Check out : http://badgerandblade.com/vb/forumdisplay.php?f=40
Good reviews here ---there's also a section on creams.

If you can say that your price is below $10.00 you can dramatically decrease your choices. A lot of the good creams are over 10 bucks.

Hope this helps.

Also check out: http://badgerandblade.com/vb/showthr...sensitive+skin

I prefer Soaps, I just like lathering up a puck. Soaps tend to be less expensive and come in an infinite variety of scents. That said there are lots of great cremes out there awaiting my use SO I can't give a purchase recommendation either.

Whether you go for soaps (convenience) or creams (my preference for moisture) you MUST try Colleen's The Gentlemen's Quarter stuff. Contact her for a price list and get some samples of both soaps and creams from her after you read the descriptions, then tell us what you think. Tell Colleen I sent you.

X

+1 on Colleen's soaps. First class, original scents, and great lather. A true joy to shave with!

RT

Colleen's stuff is great. Also Mamabear's stuff (www.bear-haven.com) is very good. If you have sensitive skin though make sure you get her Essential oil blends, NOT the Fragrance oil blends, those are not for people with sensitive skin (I know because I've tested quite a few of them).

As to your original question Soap or creams that is a tough call both have some benefits. I however prefer creams Great feel on your face Both Coleen and Mama Bear have wonderful products. I also want to throw in the mix Taylor of Old Bond Street which you can get at www.Classicshaving.com. My favorite of that group is the St James shaving cream. Also C&E Nomad is a great shaving cream also.