So my first shaving soap was a puck of VDH that got lost moving. The second was a no-name puck of soap (white label that just said "shave soap") that was lost down the toilet after one use thanks to my son, so I don't count it. That was replaced with a puck of VDH. So I finally saw the wooden bottom of my soap bowl on my last lathering which means it is just about time to acquire more soap. Since I need an alum block anyway, I shall be begging SWMBO to allow me a small SRD order. Based on everything I have read around the forum I have narrowed my choices down to three contenders: Tabac, Cella, and Mitchell's Wool Fat. I can only order one, so which should it be?