Thread: Not quite shave ready but close. What's wrong?

Originally Posted by 10Pups

You can put all your stones in a drawer and get a Norton 4/8k. You can do every thing with that and nothing without it. Or equivalent Ks.
Your driving a loaded truck and going from first gear to 10th. Lug lug lug stall :<0)

Good comparison! I almost ordered a Norton 4/8k when I first got into working with wood hand tools. I went oils instead since they don't require as much dressing to keep flat. I guess I should have gone with the Nortons!

I sand paint finishes (along with the wood working) for a living and totally get not skipping grits. You could never go from P800 to polishing in one step. It always goes P800, P1200, P1500, P2000, course buff, fine polish. So I hear your comparison!

You do not have an edge, what you are looking at is the bevel, an edge is where the bevels meet all the way from heel to toe.

If you had an edge or close to it, the 600 grit diamond plate wiped it out. And if that did not the 200 grit surely did, way too course of stone for honing.

As said for razor honing, you need much finer stones than woodworking.

A1k for bevel setting, 4k for polishing and 8k for finishing, a proper clean linen and leather strop for razors. Stropping is your final polish, the slightest grit will be much larger than the smallest grit hone… and ruin all your hard work in one stroke.

Forget about paste until you can set a bevel and finish an edge, you should be able to comfortably shave off an 8K edge. Forget about Natural stones until you can hone. Your Black Ark possibly could be used to finish, if it is a High grit Ark and properly finished for razors. Right now you don’t need a finisher you need a bevel setter and polishers.

Trust me you are not the first knife/tool guy to try and make the conversion to razors, many give up… because they think they know. The tools are similar, but not the same, neither is the technique.

A razor edge is much more fragile than a knife or tool edge. At this point do nothing until you have the proper tools and are positive of a correct course of action or send it out for honing and learn to shave.
Welcome to the forum…

Originally Posted by Euclid440

You do not have an edge, what you are looking at is the bevel, an edge is where the bevels meet all the way from heel to toe.

If you had an edge or close to it, the 600 grit diamond plate wiped it out. And if that did not the 200 grit surely did, way too course of stone for honing.

As said for razor honing, you need much finer stones than woodworking.

A1k for bevel setting, 4k for polishing and 8k for finishing, a proper clean linen and leather strop for razors. Stropping is your final polish, the slightest grit will be much larger than the smallest grit hone… and ruin all your hard work in one stroke.

Forget about paste until you can set a bevel and finish an edge, you should be able to comfortably shave off an 8K edge. Forget about Natural stones until you can hone. Your Black Ark possibly could be used to finish, if it is a High grit Ark and properly finished for razors. Right now you don’t need a finisher you need a bevel setter and polishers.

Trust me you are not the first knife/tool guy to try and make the conversion to razors, many give up… because they think they know. The tools are similar, but not the same, neither is the technique.

A razor edge is much more fragile than a knife or tool edge. At this point do nothing until you have the proper tools and are positive of a correct course of action or send it out for honing and learn to shave.
Welcome to the forum…

Not trying to sound rude but that's not what I wrote in the earlier post. I used the 200 grit to put a smile back into the blade since it was out of shape (i.e. used it to reshape only). I worked back to the Black Ark stone from there (through all the grits). I'm aware that you can't polish 200 grit scratches.

Right… so for sure you removed the edge. What did you use to set the bevel?

You can not polish an edge that does not exist.

Originally Posted by Euclid440

Right… so for sure you removed the edge. What did you use to set the bevel?

You can not polish an edge that does not exist.

I used the angle of the razor (spine and edge) flat against the stone through all the grits (200 to get back to a slight smile, 400, 600, soft ark, black ark).

Originally Posted by Wayne1963

777funk, I don't mean to sound rude, but you're going through your honing learning curve as if you possess some previous knowledge of razor craft, and you don't. One good way to learn would be to send the razor to a honemeister for sharpening, and ask them what they did, what stone progressions, etc. I personally have never used anything coarser than a 1000k grit. Prior to razor honing, I was an expert knife sharpener. That skill taught me NOTHING about razor honing. Does the touch and feel of knife sharpening carry over to razor sharpening? Initially, no, but after you gain a little skill with razor honing, there may be some transfer of skills. I learned by merging the methods of Gsixguns and Lynn Abrams and lot's of practice. Good luck.

I figured looking at the examples that I have (youtube, Lynn Abram's, etc) may help but obviously trying something for the first time is no where near mastering it! That's why I asked. I used the 200 not because the edge needed it. Contrary there... I could tell right out of the package that this old razor was already fine enough to go straight to the black ark, or at the coursest, assuming the bevel needed touching up, the soft ark. I went to 200 mid this thread, not to refine the edge, but because I wanted to correct the geometry (had a few dips that kept it from being straight - I brought it to a slight smile which would have taken forever with anything finer than the 200).

BTW, I didn't mean to sound frustrated in my last post (#26). I looked back and it probably sounded that way. But I feel I am being misunderstood by several posters here. I'm aware that you don't sharpen/hone anything with 200. I used it not to sharpen but to reshape. The edge had some dips (frowns) in it. I used the course 200 and careful swooping passes to get these out. As in my original post, I used arks initially to hone this razor. After someone mentioned the frown I checked it with a straight edge (which of course isn't good for the edge in and of itself) and sure enough there were frowns/dips. ONLY because of this, I went to the 200 to get these out. That also said, I'm not trying to sound like I know what I'm doing... I've never sharpened a SR before this week! So I sure don't. But, I do understand the basics and I'm plenty familiar with grits and understand that you do not sharpen with 200. I used it to reshape. I'm sure whoever shapes these razors when new isn't using 2000 grit to do it. Neither would I.

“That would be a big jump, no I brought it back up through to the black (200, 300, 400, 600, soft ark, then black)”

Assuming this is what you have available, these are all natural stones, except the 600 diamond plate?
Post photos of your stones.

I have never use anything courser than a 600 and that is for removing ¼ in size chips. 1K for 99 percent of all work, anything courser will leave deep stria that will have to be removed and may cause chipping down the road in the finer grits.

Unless you can grit rate the Arks and get one in the 800 -1k range, (all natural stone are different, especially Arks) your best bet is to buy a synthetic progression 1, 4 & 8k and lap you stones, on 325 wet and dry.

Tape the spine with 2 layers of tape, to protect it and set the bevel on the 1k, stay on the 1K doing circles or half laps in sets of 20, until the bevel is set and you have created a…edge, a sharp even edge.

You first have to make an edge, (hone the two bevels flat so they meet in a straight, burr free edge). And do so at 800 to 1k, anything courser will cause chipping later in the finish grits of the progression.

Anything less and you are bevel setting for hours especially, after a 200 grit honing all that stria has to be removed.

Look straight down at the edge with magnification and strong light, if you see reflections, the bevels are not meeting. Stay on the 1k until you no longer see light reflecting back. Change you tape frequently, you will burn through it and ruin the spine.

Diamond and novices are notorious for causing chipping edges, then the edge must be removed and start over.

An experienced honer can bevel set with a Washita and finish on a Surgical Black with the right stones and properly prepared for razors and several hundreds of laps.

I know it can be frustrating to have folks tell you, you’re doing it wrong, but when we say honing a razor is different than a knife or tool… it is.

Add to all that, you are going to put the edge to your face, it has to be extremely sharp and comfortable. Finishing on 8K grits or higher with a very lite touch will give you comfort if the bevel and edge have a good foundation, a properly established bevel and progression or the edge will not hold and crumble or chip.

Here is bevel that is partially set, the white line on the right is not set, the left side is. Once you no longer see white lite reflecting the bevels are meeting, you cannot see the edge, it is that thin. The red is tape.

Originally Posted by Euclid440

“That would be a big jump, no I brought it back up through to the black (200, 300, 400, 600, soft ark, then black)”

Assuming this is what you have available, these are all natural stones, except the 600 diamond plate?
Post photos of your stones.

I have never use anything courser than a 600 and that is for removing ¼ in size chips. 1K for 99 percent of all work, anything courser will leave deep stria that will have to be removed and may cause chipping down the road in the finer grits.

Unless you can grit rate the Arks and get one in the 800 -1k range, (all natural stone are different, especially Arks) your best bet is to buy a synthetic progression 1, 4 & 8k and lap you stones, on 325 wet and dry.

Tape the spine with 2 layers of tape, to protect it and set the bevel on the 1k, stay on the 1K doing circles or half laps in sets of 20, until the bevel is set and you have created a…edge, a sharp even edge.

You first have to make an edge, (hone the two bevels flat so they meet in a straight, burr free edge). And do so at 800 to 1k, anything courser will cause chipping later in the finish grits of the progression.

Anything less and you are bevel setting for hours especially, after a 200 grit honing all that stria has to be removed.

Look straight down at the edge with magnification and strong light, if you see reflections, the bevels are not meeting. Stay on the 1k until you no longer see light reflecting back. Change you tape frequently, you will burn through it and ruin the spine.

Diamond and novices are notorious for causing chipping edges, then the edge must be removed and start over.

An experienced honer can bevel set with a Washita and finish on a Surgical Black with the right stones and properly prepared for razors and several hundreds of laps.

I know it can be frustrating to have folks tell you, you’re doing it wrong, but when we say honing a razor is different than a knife or tool… it is.

Add to all that, you are going to put the edge to your face, it has to be extremely sharp and comfortable. Finishing on 8K grits or higher with a very lite touch will give you comfort if the bevel and edge have a good foundation, a properly established bevel and progression or the edge will not hold and crumble or chip.

Here is bevel that is partially set, the white line on the right is not set, the left side is. Once you no longer see white lite reflecting the bevels are meeting, you cannot see the edge, it is that thin. The red is tape.

The picture you posted is basic and applies to all sharpening. If I could see a reflection looking straight onto the edge/bevel, the blade wouldn't cut anything (maybe butter). There is no reflection coming from my edge and it cuts hair. I've even shaved with it but it feels like a disposable that's been used a few times. It's sharp but not quite sharp enough. I can easily shave chest hair or an arm with it, so it is sharp.

As far as the grits go, (I feel like I'm echoing myself), I used the 200 ONLY to reshape since the blade had some frowns. This is an antique razor we're talking about. It was out of shape in the litteral sense of the word. I realize that you wouldn't normally use anything courser than 600 or even 1000 unless something was bad wrong. This is exactly what I'm saying... I had to reshape the blade.

My stones are diamond up to 1000 (Diasharp is my 1000, Harbor Freight on the courser ones), Hall's Pro Edge for the two Ark stones (soft and Surgical Black).