Thread: Does anyone have any experience with this strop paste?

It is a good product, the red paste is medium fine and black is fine.

It is made by Herold, who also make strops.

Originally Posted by Badgister

It is a good product, the red paste is medium fine and black is fine.

It is made by Herold, who also make strops.

Many thanks! And fine with a hanging strop?

The stats that they gave years ago, yes they work fine with a hanging leather strop as long as you do your job
I have found these to be very well matched to the older softer Sheffield steels

Green 5-8 micron
Red 3-5 micron
Black 1-3 micron
Soligen pastes are a much more mild cutter then say a diamond paste of the same micron size...

Originally Posted by gssixgun

The stats that they gave years ago, yes they work fine with a hanging leather strop as long as you do your job
I have found these to be very well matched to the older softer Sheffield steels

Green 5-8 micron
Red 3-5 micron
Black 1-3 micron
Soligen pastes are a much more mild cutter then say a diamond paste of the same micron size...

Many thanks!

A general question: I have seen in various sources that the cutting particles in a 4000 grit stone are 4-5 microns (eg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharpening_stone). I have also seen chromium oxide powder and red ferric oxide powder advertised with particle sizes of 0.5 and 0.3 micron respectively (eg https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/264631273241).

I know there is much more to abrasive quality that the size of the cutting particle, but how do I square these numbers with the particle size in the list above for the Herold pastes?

So, there is grit (partial) size and there is finish quality. A lot depends on the grit, is it friable, (will it break down further), how deep will it cut, (partial shape) and the substrate, (does the grit imbed into the substrate, leather vs wood). All affect the ability to “Polish”.

Take Arks and Jnats, some say all Ark grit and Jnat grit respectively are the same and the difference is in the concentration and binder.

Bottom line, it is not just about grit size. Add to all that steel, substrate hanging vs paddle and technique, are why paste works for some and not for others, your mileage may vary.

Here are photos from an old post on the effects of pressure, (just one variable)

I use those postes on my SRD modular paddle strop and am very happy with the results

After the advice, I got some of the Herold hard strop pastes, and pasted up one of the cotton webbing strops:



First impressions are that the black paste is where it's at. The red seems a bit like the green (pre-loaded on my Herold loom strop) in quality, just finer. The black seems to be really smooth, and though I need a few more laps, it really seems to add keenness to the edge. Anyway, I will experiment, and get to know these compounds.

Originally Posted by Euclid440

...

Before you paste a strop, you may want to paste a piece of cardboard, (inside of a cereal box) and experiment using as a paddle strop. Paste a strop once you find a paste that works best. Once applied to a linen or leather strop it can never be completely removed. ...

For anyone wanting to experiment with stropping, I have definitely found this suggestion very useful. You can put anything on a piece of card and try it. I just tried tailor's chalk:



(for anyone interested, the tailor's chalk left very fine scratches in the bevel, which polished out quickly with stropping on plain fabric; it could definitely be used for stropping, and I'd suggest it could be used to refresh a slightly dulled edge. I'm not going to use it regularly, because it doesn't really add anything new to the toolkit)

Many thanks!