Quote Originally Posted by jwy77 View Post
I use Neatsfoot oil as the suspension, I have treated a strop with Neatsfoot and powdered Crox, works great, the oil keeps the leather in good shape and the Crox gives it the right amount of grit. Not sure how chalk or soapstone dust would hold up in the oil though.
Stole the words right out of my mouth.

Plus, I think neatsfoot would have a higher viscosity, causing chalk to immulsify more easily