I just finished installing a set of G10 scales on this old Wade & Butcher that belonged to my Grandpa. When I recieved the razor it had a large chip out of the heal. I sanded this out as best as possible. The scales turned out good with the exception of finishing them. They are dull.

Does anyone have any suggestions on how to make them shine?

I tried buffing them, wet sanding them, buffing with polishing compound. Nothing has worked well yet.