Thread: Would you replace the scales?

Originally Posted by holli4pirating

If you would enjoy them more, then go for it.

Personally, I'd only replace broken scales. I tend to like the conservative, vintage look even with custom scales.

+1. My attitude in a nutshell.

sure but only if they are good shavers makes no sense to waste money on nice handles if they dont give a good shave

I replace the scales on most of my razors to something that looks a little nicer. Having said that, none of my razors came with fancy scales or are hugely collectible. I like personalising and restoring old things, that is one of the reasons I got into straights. Unless the removing the scales dramatically reduces the razors value I say go for it.

I would probably plan to replace them but never do it. The second razor I bought was a Wapienica. I looked at it and said, "Those sterile, heavy scales have got to go." When it came right down to it, I just couldn't bring myself to change them. I have a nice old W&B with horn scales. They're old, dull, chipped. I just can't destroy such nice old work. My first razor, a Revisor had beautiful black scales that just had to go. They were cracked at the pivot and I had no choice. Undream replaced them for me at th Michigan meet this past summer. They're gorgeous. I highly recommend his work. (But I still haven't had the heart to throw out the old ones).

It depends on several factors:
a) Are the razors outstanding shavers? If not; forget them.
b) Are the scales warped or otherwise damaged?
If you answer yes to the questions above; go ahead.
(Posting pictures makes it easier to answer.)

I have had scales replaced by Glen (gssixgun) and Max (Maximilan).
They both did outstanding work.

I think what is at the core of your question is what is your romance in straight razor shaving.

1. Is it the process of using a straight razor and any good one will suffice?
2. Is it the process of using vintage steel?
3. Is it the process of using a vintage razor in its entirety - scales and all?

Maybe it is a mix of all three?

When you figure that out, you can answer your own question.

Personally, I would only replace broken scales - but that is because it is about number 3 for me with a touch of 1.