scales

[bg42]

I`m experimenting with different shapes ,sorry about the pic ,its not that flash,anyway Im not sure if I like the shape of these,they will probably end up in the bin.
The used to make coke style folders so I thought I would try the same shape with one set of scales.
An honest evaluation would be appreciated ,they are approx 3/32" thick
Kind regards Peter

[FiReSTaRT]

Peter,
I like the shape of the top set but the bottom set isn't something I'd mate to my project razors. I guess I'm a big fan of simplicity.

[urleebird]

I like the top set a little better. They are both a tad busy, but may work just fine with the right blade. The bottom set needs a big smilie blade, for sure.

[xChris]

The top set doesn't remind me at all of the "Coke Bottle" shape, but is the better balanced design of the two.

The bottom set, IMO, needs a thicker "neck," a flatter top, and a straighter overall line to them to better capture your inspiration.

[bg42]

thanks for your honesty ,just quietly I think they will both end up in the bin
Kind regards Peter

[urleebird]

thanks for your honesty ,just quietly I think they will both end up in the bin
Kind regards Peter

Betcha my bin's bigger n your bin...

[xman]

I kinda like them both. I've often wondered what the most ergonomic design would be for scales and whether or not something that thins and wraps arounf the tang finger, like the bottom set might, wouldn't be more comfortable.

X

[grottolord]

befor you throw them in your bin
mail them to me and ill put them on some of my blades
i think they look fine its just a matter of fit.
Happpy holidays mike

[bg42]

befor you throw them in your bin
mail them to me and ill put them on some of my blades
i think they look fine its just a matter of fit.
Happpy holidays mike

Sorry mate too late, they have been chucked,otherwise you would have been quite welcome
Kind regards Peter