Hey guys,
I am trying to clean up a razor. It has what look like water marks on it, maybe tarnish, but nothing serious like pitting. I had some high grade sandpaper from another project lying around (1000, 1500, and 2000). I used this to remove the mark, now i've got tiny scratches that I wanted to polish out. I started with polishing by hand, but that proved imposssible to notice a difference, so I went to a buffing pad on my dremel. Even that doesn't seem to take the fine lines out.

I'm using NOXON, though I tried Braso (which was under the sink used for the dishes), and neither seem to help very much. I see that everyone suggests MAAS, or even Flitz or Simichrome; however, I can pick up MAAS at walmart without having to order online.

Is Maas much better than Noxon or Braso? I hate to keep buying redundant products, and it seems like metal polish would be metal polish... no?