Quote Originally Posted by jgeidson87 View Post
Felt wheel on a drill ok? I can't go buy a grinder just yet. Should I go back down to like 320 and work back up?
Absolutely! Looks like you got most of the scratches out already. I would maybe do some 1500 and 2000 again, then rogue on a felt wheel on a drill. Make sure you carefully wipe all dust from the sandpaper before you start buffing. Tiny metal filings will otherwise get stuck in the wheel and you will make new scratches.

After having at it with the rogue you need a second felt wheel with nothing on just for the final buffing.

Remember, all this is easier with a magnetic jig (search on this site if you don't already have made one). It is also safer since you will not suddenly have the blade fly out of your hand and break on the floor.