Thread: Oldest straight razor on eBay?

Originally Posted by Ryan82

Are you perhaps thinking about John Mitchell?

Nope. This razor was ridiculously priced, way over that one .

I added it to my watch list... Will be fun to see if he unloads it.

Interesting TV show reference. I can't remember if that particular show is the one where the family keeps pushing African American people out the shop (who seem to be the only customers) or the one with the overweight tattooed fellows with the old father? Regardless, I'd have no idea if they knew anything at all about straight razors.

Surely, one thing that COULD be said, is that it's be nearly impossible to state if the scales are original. I am no expert, but I'm been racking my brains to think how one could be so sure of that as to state it as a fact.

Originally Posted by carlmaloschneider

Surely, one thing that COULD be said, is that it's be nearly impossible to state if the scales are original. I am no expert, but I'm been racking my brains to think how one could be so sure of that as to state it as a fact.

You make a good point Carl , I really can't prove beyond any doubt , that the scales are not original to the razor . On the other hand , I would like to know who can prove beyond any doubt , that the scales are original to the razor . If you look at the pics (crappy as they are) it seems obvious , to me , that the scales are too narrow for the blade , and if you close the razor , I think the edge of the blade would be sticking out of the bottom of the scales . Which could be why the seller doesn't show a pic of the razor in the closed position .

Originally Posted by dave5225

You make a good point Carl , I really can't prove beyond any doubt , that the scales are not original to the razor . On the other hand , I would like to know who can prove beyond any doubt , that the scales are original to the razor . If you look at the pics (crappy as they are) it seems obvious , to me , that the scales are too narrow for the blade , and if you close the razor , I think the edge of the blade would be sticking out of the bottom of the scales . Which could be why the seller doesn't show a pic of the razor in the closed position .

Yeah, that's sort of what I'm saying, esp for old razors. I guess we could guess that an old razor with nicely worn horn scales and what look to be original pins is all original, but it must be hart to really know. I think 'mass produced' razors (I'm thinking of my Burrell Top Flight with it's cheap (plastic?) scales can be proven to be original just by knowing that so many were turned out with the same scales. I think any with wooden, and even horn etc scales would be harder to determine in this regard.

I have an old De Pews, with what looks like horn scales, and al old Jernbolaget with what I am told are leather scales. However, if I were to advertise them, I wouldn't say they ARE original, as there really is no way for me to know that. I'd probably say they LOOK to be original, or simply 'have what apear to be quite old scales' :-)

Anyway, I have too many other things begging for my money (like the wife) to afford 300 buckeroonies on ANY razor, original and rare or not. Some of my favorite razors were cheapies, the Burrell Top Flight is an example, even with its cheap scales!

The thing i ben thinking be funny if it was that seller who posted the question.
Cause a new person to straight razor shaving will never pay that kind of money.
Someone who ben using them for along time be really picky about what they spend alot of money on.

Originally Posted by Suile

The thing i ben thinking be funny if it was that seller who posted the question.
Cause a new person to straight razor shaving will never pay that kind of money.
Someone who ben using them for along time be really picky about what they spend alot of money on.

Well then he is very much a salesman then isn't he. I mean he puts' it up for what he thinks it's worth and then maybe hits all the forums to advertise for free. I am sure he will get his 20% e-Bay fee back. He put a reserve on it so he won't lose it. Got to give him an A+ for effort that is for sure. He is shooting for the moon. I don't think he is going to make it but nothing in this world surprises me anymore.

Originally Posted by Suile

The thing i ben thinking be funny if it was that seller who posted the question.
Cause a new person to straight razor shaving will never pay that kind of money.
Someone who ben using them for along time be really picky about what they spend alot of money on.

That never even crossed my mind, but come to think of it, if you're wondering about someone else's item, the language "Thanks in advance for the feedback" is a little weird.

Originally Posted by carlmaloschneider

Interesting TV show reference. I can't remember if that particular show is the one where the family keeps pushing African American people out the shop (who seem to be the only customers) or the one with the overweight tattooed fellows with the old father? Regardless, I'd have no idea if they knew anything at all about straight razors.

Surely, one thing that COULD be said, is that it's be nearly impossible to state if the scales are original. I am no expert, but I'm been racking my brains to think how one could be so sure of that as to state it as a fact.

In case you care (and hopefully you don't). The first show you describe is called Hard Core Pawn and is set in Detroit Michigan in a very rough area of a very rough town...I used to work down the street from this place. I believe it is probably a much more accurate depiction of what happens in most pawn shops...I could be wrong.

The second show you describe is Pawn Stars, and is the one referenced in the eBay listing....and I am inclined to agree with your conjecture that these fellows have no idea (or at least not a similar idea to OURS) about straight razors and their value.

Both shows are entertaining...just like these 24 hour news networks...but perhaps none of them should be trusted implicitly for unbiased information

The Pawn Star store is in Las Vegas and is very much a tourist trap. My brother went there to check it out while he was in Vegas and said the line out the door was about a 20 minute wait. Good luck talking to one of the stars unless you have an appointment or flash some big bucks. After he got in he said there was a section that you see on TV and another that you could afford to shop in. Most people bought something just to have bragging rights but as my Bro said...." I wouldn't spend a buck on what that guy paid 20 dollars for. And he thought he got a great . This is my brothers story about it and I have no interest in such a folly so as to go see for myself. When I am in Vegas it is to stop for gas on my way somewhere else. If I feel like gambling I throw 5 bucks out the window while on the freeway and that cures it. If I am lucky I don't get a ticket for littering.