Thanks for all of the help everyone! This forum is amazingly active.

Well first thing I'm going to try is another shave tomorrow with the same setup. Putting a bit more time into my stropping (I'll try 80 like was suggested) and working with my lather more.

I also ordered some soap from the gentleman's refinery which was uber-expensive but highly recommended. I checked out moma bear, but her website confused me too much

I'll try again tommor and return my results. Again thanks for all of the suggestions!