iam a soap guy so far dr harris gets the nod for great lather, scent, and ease of use. Poraso give you great glide too if you liked vaper rub you will love Poraso .tabac is hard to beat the price and its easy to lather.you can face lather with the creams allways worked well for me.of the soaps you listed i would go with tabac frist SDR second and then Poraso. i have used all three and have been happy with them all