Quote Originally Posted by JMIdeker View Post
I have a Straight Razor Designs 3 inch premium leather strop.
I believe SRD sells replacement leather for all of their strops. I have replaced the leather on a strop from them in the past, as I nicked my first one up real good.

If the nicks are at the top or the bottom, you should be able to avoid them and still strop well. If they're in a tough spot towards the middle of the strop's length, I'd consider replacing the leather.