Personally I would never accept someone else's word or opinion as to whether or not a razor is "shave ready." I don't care who they are, or say they are, or how long they've been involved with straight razors, etc. What another considers shave ready may not be, or at least may not be according to your standards.

I think it is important, sooner than later, to learn to judge a razors "shave readiness" for yourself.

A few possibilities:

1) Your razor might be keen enough for a good shave, but your technique is lacking.
2) Your shaving technique might be OK, but your razor not quite keen enough.
3) You may need to improve on both.

If you can at least eliminate one factor, the shave ready factor, then you'll know that it's not your razor, but your shaving technique that needs work.