Thread: I need a "REAL" Brush..Simpson or Thater ???

I'd save yourself some money and go for the Semogue 2013 SE. That was by far the best badger brush I owned/tried until I found synthetics. Super dense, soft tips, great looking olive wood handle and decent backbone.

There is no bad choice between Simpson and Thater. Both have nice backbones and hold suds very well. They both work well with soaps and creams. Thater might have softer tips vs. the scritchy from Simpson which some folks like a lot.

Have fun.

Originally Posted by Lb1

I'd save yourself some money and go for the Semogue 2013 SE. That was by far the best badger brush I owned/tried until I found synthetics. Super dense, soft tips, great looking olive wood handle and decent backbone.

My son has one of those...nice brush too, never lost any hairs

I have a Simpson that I use for creams mostly, it is a great brush. I can not comment on Thater though as I do not have one (at this current time).

My go to brush of the 3 I own is one that "pixelfixed" made. I can without a doubt say that if you get a brush from him that you will use it often. I also have to comment on his willingness to make sure things are right. He was not happy with the way the first knot was and informed me that he had ordered a new knot for it. He clearly stands behind his product and is willing to ensure that everything is is in tip top shape.

Keep in mind that you may want 2 good brushes at the minimum if you use both soaps and creams. I like the softer brushes for the cream and one with a bit more bite (stiffness) for the soaps.

Originally Posted by PHANTZM

I have a Simpson that I use for creams mostly, it is a great brush. I can not comment on Thater though as I do not have one (at this current time).

My go to brush of the 3 I own is one that "pixelfixed" made. I can without a doubt say that if you get a brush from him that you will use it often. I also have to comment on his willingness to make sure things are right. He was not happy with the way the first knot was and informed me that he had ordered a new knot for it. He clearly stands behind his product and is willing to ensure that everything is is in tip top shape.

Keep in mind that you may want 2 good brushes at the minimum if you use both soaps and creams. I like the softer brushes for the cream and one with a bit more bite (stiffness) for the soaps.

May I ask....what was wrong with the first knot ????

Originally Posted by nessmuck

May I ask....what was wrong with the first knot ????

I honestly don't know. I did not ask. He said he was not happy with it and was going to replace it as soon as the new one came in. I don't know that I would have noticed, but he did and did not like it.

I own both brushes, and it is a difficult choice................ Both are fantastic brushes, and you will not regret either you choose.

Other than,as you are a face lather the Thater has a much smaller handle, whereas the Polo 8 has a much longer handle, ideal for bowl lather. As you say the Thater has a much bigger knot over Polo 8, still very easy to navigate the face, and wonder soft tips.

Whichever you purchase "or both" Enjoy.


Charles U.K

Just talked with Don @ straight razor design ....and the Simpson is on its way !!!!!

nessmuck,

You will love the Polo 8 in super badger. It does wonders for face lathering whether you use soap or cream. I love mine. No, as Lynn noted, it will not have the silky tips of the Tather silvertip, but then, in my experience, no other brush model does. The Thater is in its class for silky tips. The Simpson Polo 8 in super also has extremely soft tips, great backbone, and I love the tall handle. You made a good choice.

You can't really go wrong with either. I prefer the English style and flair that goes with Simpson, and I own quite a few, but if I had to keep only one it would be my Thäter 26mm - 2 band brush. Hands down the most luxurious brush with excellent backbone for my own personal taste. Either way, congrats on your new purchase.