Thread: On Climate Change and Evolution

Reading the current thread on Climate Change and previous threads on Evolution, it occurred to me that there are a lot of similarities in the two discussions.

So this poll is an unscientific way of seeing if there is a correlation of some kind. I hope everyone will read the two statements below and vote above on their position.

Statement A: Global Warming is occurring. Humans are causing it.

Statement B: Humans are descended from animals who were not human. All living things have a common ancestor.

Please vote!

I went for the last option.

Because I do not think we have enough definitive evidence to say either one either way.

At some point our interferring with nature just has to stop! Wouldn't you think that we humans could have been satisfied with killing off all those dinosaurs? But NO!! Then we had to melt all those icecaps and glaciers and now we're at it again. Or is that still?

I feel so ashamed.

Originally Posted by Bruce

At some point our interferring with nature just has to stop! Wouldn't you think that we humans could have been satisfied with killing off all those dinosaurs? But NO!! Then we had to melt all those icecaps and glaciers and now we're at it again.

Boys will be boys.

I chose B True and A False.

But I want to clarify. I do believe that global warming is occurring, but I believe it is as part of a natural cycle. That being said, I really do think that we as a species could be a whole lot nicer to our environment, regardless of the whole global warming issue.

My simple answer for the purpose of what I feel the "nature" of the question is, would be A.
However, due to the fact that these are highly complex qeustions that are so over-simplified in these answers (as they need to be, really , to make a poll out of...nto bashing the poll or thread, here), that nothing but "other" can be a really accurate/honest assesment of how I feel/what I believe the science points to.

If A & B are both true, doe sthat mean that global warming is the peak of evolution?

I voted 'other' because I don't know. Seems to me that we are mammals with just enough intellect to give us an ego that thinks we are something more special than our chimp cousins and that we are the 'made in the image or God'. I don't know where we came from or where we are going but it seems that the majority of the scientific community believes that 'we' are contributing to the global warming phenomenon.

So you think there is a direct connection between people (read Americans) who do not believe in Darwinism and those who do not believe in AGW... or not? I do not see any other purpose this thread could possibly have.

I do believe there is a shift in the global climate occuring, and I think that humans are certainly contributing to it, but I am not ready to say that humans are causing it.

I do believe that humans are descended from animals (which are non-humans), but I am not sure there is evidence that points towards a single ancestor.

As such, I am voting that I think both statements are false.

I would also like to say that I, too, am curious as to what "correlation" you are investigating.