Used to use the Nivea balm for years. Since I work outside and in a dirty environment I found it was like a dirt attractant some times. So now I use it only if I shave on a day off. For my work day shaves I only use Thayer witch hazel as a finisher. Cooling and it doesn't hang around and make you greasy. If I am going out with the wife for date night I will normally match aftershave to cream/soap scent. Needless to say that gets pricey.