Thread: French Vosgienne

I got my French Vosgienne today and I thought I'd share. I saw something real similar on here a long time ago and no one seemed to know what it was so I'm guessing there not commen. Also if anyone knows anything else about this stone I would like to know.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

Also it looks like someone painted the sides at some point and was scrubbed off at some point. Is this something I should be worried about. I've heard of Japanese stones being laminated on the sides to keep them from falling apart. It dosent smell like oil at all.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

In the width measure pic it looks to have writing, what does it say? looks like a date to the right and above?

How does the stone hone>??

I haven't tried honing with it yet. But if you're referring to the picture with the tape measure in it believe that they are embedded fossils.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

Well, it is a good looking stone, did you get a good price on it?

I would say its a slate...i own several slates like this. Actually its difficult to point out the origin of any of those.

Mottled slate appears in many different regions of the world...

Iam actually trying to get some analyses done from a geologist. To get thin cuts of some stones. This would be the only way to try to compare those samples with others beeing already done.

The coloration comes from a Redox reaction.
Red comes from Hematite, green comes from Chlinochlor....

I also talked about "Vosgian Stones" to a certain time for my stones. I have to admit today this Term cant be proofed in detail....

Here are some pictures:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/razorl...57650718803678

Here is a sample of a mottled Vermont Slate:

Originally Posted by FAL

Well, it is a good looking stone, did you get a good price on it?

I'm not sure. I paid $110 for it shipped. At first the guy didn't know what it was, but when I messaged him asking if it was a finisher he messaged me back saying that one of the ebay shoppers told him it was a Vosgienne razor hone. It's 8in x 1.5in

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

Originally Posted by doorsch

I would say its a slate...i own several slates like this. Actually its difficult to point out the origin of any of those.

Mottled slate appears in many different regions of the world...

Iam actually trying to get some analyses done from a geologist. To get thin cuts of some stones. This would be the only way to try to compare those samples with others beeing already done.

The coloration comes from a Redox reaction.
Red comes from Hematite, green comes from Chlinochlor....

I also talked about "Vosgian Stones" to a certain time for my stones. I have to admit today this Term cant be proofed in detail....

Here are some pictures:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/razorl...57650718803678

Here is a sample of a mottled Vermont Slate:

Do you think it would be a good idea to seal the edges? I'm worried about using it since it seems someone sealed the edges in the past. I don't want to destroy the stone.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

Originally Posted by aaron1234

Do you think it would be a good idea to seal the edges? I'm worried about using it since it seems someone sealed the edges in the past. I don't want to destroy the stone.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

Especially on slates there is a easy procedure to check if a Sealing might be useful...make the area where you want to check the condition wet...then directly dry it with a towel...

Now check how fast the surface gets dry...if there a bigger cracks inside the stone they will remain wet and look darker....

If you have many cracks i would personally seal a slate, if not a sealing is not needed

Originally Posted by doorsch

Especially on slates there is a easy procedure to check if a Sealing might be useful...make the area where you want to check the condition wet...then directly dry it with a towel...

Now check how fast the surface gets dry...if there a bigger cracks inside the stone they will remain wet and look darker....

If you have many cracks i would personally seal a slate, if not a sealing is not needed

This Stone holds water incredibly well so it differently needs to be sealed. Do you have any suggestions on what to seal it with( preferably something clear so that way I can still see the grain)? Also is there any special care for a stone like this?

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk