Results 1 to 10 of 55
Hybrid View
-
07-17-2011, 06:06 PM #1
Hi Sharpman
Without actually trying out the particular "hard stone" I would venture to guess that some hard stones do cut very fast at first because they are loaded with grit. But if the swarf from the steel blade is not carried away in some manner, the stone will become loaded with compressed cleaved grit particles that are essencially welded into the voids of the stones surface along with ground off steel. This glazed stone will at this stage stop being a hone but more like a burnishing plate. Here again some people think that a bright shiny blade must be sharper, but I suggest that the metallurgical changes necessary to polish a blade a blade by burnishing will have mixed consequences including destruction of the temper of the steel maybe by a few points, and an ultra thin but very fragile edge that will only last a few shaves at best.
My Shapton 30k on glass becomes black when I use it, the grit is so sharp and the action is so fast and the stone so hard that the black metal filings just have no where to go but to fill up the surface voids of the stone. Do I just continue to use a stone that was pure white but is just becoming blacker and blacker? Or should I lap the stone to clean off the swarf and in doing so reveal fresh grit? When does the 30k start acting like a burnishing plate?
Also I like your idea of testing the hardness, totally sensual and empiric and based on observation. And the ping of a stone will deduce consistancy and reveal any imperfectons. The water test has some cautions with japanese stone. Some miners coated the top surface of freshly surfaced stones ready for market with an eggwash to prevent the soiling of the surface with grime and dirt. And also I have found that Jnats will over time from a natural oxidized film that is microns thin, both of these issues will imped water. So unless the stone is lapped, but with a used stone the water could be uses as an indicator. I have to agree that a dense stone will be more compact and will shed water more easily than a porous (more voids between physical particles) but also a dense stone may be less porous because of a high concentration of binders.
-
The Following User Says Thank You to alx For This Useful Post:
JimmyHAD (07-17-2011)