Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 16
Like Tree4Likes

Thread: Oil

  1. #1
    Nic by name not by nature Jeltz's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    South West England
    Posts
    961
    Thanked: 249

    Default Oil

    I've read of some people using oil on some natural hones (yellow lake and CF) to get a better edge than with water, why would that work?

    I'm considering trying oil on my Dragons Tongue hone, would mineral oil be OK and if I did would it "ruin" the stone for future use with water.
    Regards
    Nic

  2. #2
    illegitimum non carborundum Utopian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Rochester, MN
    Posts
    11,544
    Thanked: 3795
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    Mineral oil is way too thick. Basically you want the thinnest oil you can get.

    Regarding "ruining it," I don't know about that stone in particular, as I have not yet gotten one due to my continued annoyance over the shipping charge, but in general it is difficult to transition from oil back to water.

  3. #3
    Nic by name not by nature Jeltz's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    South West England
    Posts
    961
    Thanked: 249

    Default

    Ahhh well I've just logged in and found your message after trying it!

    I had just honed a razor with my coticule "Kukri Finest Silver Steel", it was good enough but not perfect. The HHT was passable but not perfect. So I oiled up the DT and did 20 laps stropped and retested the HHT. There was a slight improvement so I repeated the sequence and again there was an improvement such that the HHT was very good. I know that the HHT isn't regarded as very reliable but the fine hair from my daughters hairbrush has tends to give me a decent indication.

    Previously the DT on water has had a negative effect after my coti, so the oil approach seems on the face of it beneficial, but the true test will be tomorrow's shave.
    Regards
    Nic

  4. #4
    illegitimum non carborundum Utopian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Rochester, MN
    Posts
    11,544
    Thanked: 3795
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    I've got doubts about the ability of a DT, even with oil, improving the edge off a coticule

  5. #5
    Senior Member Caledonian's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Saudi Arabia and Scotland
    Posts
    314
    Thanked: 60

    Default

    It's true that if you use oil, it ought to be the thinnest you can get. I don't know whathere "mineral oil" denotes some specific type, but any suitable oil, if such a thing there be, would be of mineral origin. Vegetable oils dry and leave residues. I have seen WD40 recommended here for use with wet and dry paper, and the same might apply to a hone.

    I'm doubtful whether the use of oil confers any advantage. Honing woodworking tools etc. produces larger quanties of clogging steel residue. Water can be used, but as it evaporates, needs to be more frequently renewed. I think that is the only real advantage of using less volatile oil, and wouldn't apply so much with the much smaller metal residue from honing razors.

    Oil does penetrate into a stone, and unlike oil, doesn't evaporate away. A new carborundum carpenter's stone, for example, is often stood in oil to saturate it. This will exclude water, so it might be a good idea to stand the stone for a while in some volatile solvent, such as gasoline or acetone, if the change from oil to water is to be made.
    Last edited by Caledonian; 06-21-2011 at 09:13 PM.

  6. #6
    Senior Member blabbermouth niftyshaving's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Silicon Valley, CA, USA
    Posts
    3,157
    Thanked: 852

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Jeltz View Post
    I've read of some people using oil on some natural hones (yellow lake and CF) to get a better edge than with water, why would that work?

    I'm considering trying oil on my Dragons Tongue hone, would mineral oil be OK and if I did would it "ruin" the stone for future use with water.
    Why?
    The answer is not obvious and short of testing and
    science there is no way to know.

    A problem with oil is that there is almost no turning back.
    Solvents can recover some hone rocks.

    In an old box for a carborundum brand barber hone is
    a comment that if the hone is too aggressive
    soak it in Vaseline. So oil thick or thin can change
    how a hone cuts.

    All hones need something to cool, lubricate and
    clean (the right amount) the surface of the hone
    and the steel being sharpened.

    Over time folk have tried almost everything under
    the sun and the best pairing is what most folk do.

    Oil has an advantage of protecting the steel
    from corrosion. Water has the advantage of
    letting the steel corrode a bit. Water can cause
    clay in some naturals to swell. Water can
    also react with minerals and change the micro
    chemistry at the edge (abrasion pH).

    Caution some resin bound man made hones could
    turn to sloppy goo with the wrong solvent or oil.

    Dragons Tongue hone's are slate and slate is
    almost impervious to water. I think this impervious
    to water tips the preference for slate hones
    toward oil.

    I would love it if someone near me was to
    slice one of the old slate chalk black boards into
    3"x14" slabs and sell me one inexpensively.
    Last edited by niftyshaving; 06-22-2011 at 04:02 AM. Reason: typo
    nun2sharp and Jeltz like this.

  7. The Following User Says Thank You to niftyshaving For This Useful Post:

    Utopian (06-21-2011)

  8. #7
    Nic by name not by nature Jeltz's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    South West England
    Posts
    961
    Thanked: 249

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Utopian View Post
    I've got doubts about the ability of a DT, even with oil, improving the edge off a coticule
    Agreed, there is of course the likelihood that had I returned that razor to the coti I would have improved the edge as well. However, the aim was more to find the best use of my DT it seems as though not all DT's are the same mine is very hard and took ages to lap. In previous use with water the DT has barely improved the edge I get coming off a king 6K. The shave will tell all tomorrow, but I don't have an issue with continuing using oil on it as it was a cheap hone.
    Regards
    Nic

  9. #8
    Nic by name not by nature Jeltz's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    South West England
    Posts
    961
    Thanked: 249

    Default

    Result of test shave was very sharp and very crisp with no irritation. It was an improvement on the edge I had and vastly better than any edge I've produced with the DT before. It felt different to a coticule edge maybe not quite as mellow, I shall persist with testing this technique at this stage I'm not sure which edge I prefer.
    Regards
    Nic

  10. #9
    The Hurdy Gurdy Man thebigspendur's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    New Mexico
    Posts
    32,737
    Thanked: 5016
    Blog Entries
    4

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by niftyshaving View Post
    Why?
    The answer is not obvious and short of testing and
    science there is no way to know.

    A problem with oil is that there is almost no turning back.
    Solvents can recover some hone rocks.

    In an old box for a carborundum brand barber hone is
    a comment that if the hone is too aggressive
    soak it in Vaseline. So oil thick or thin can change
    how a hone cuts.

    All hones need something to cool, lubricate and
    clean (the right amount) the surface of the hone
    and the steel being sharpened.

    Over time folk have tried almost everything under
    the sun and the best pairing is what most folk do.

    Oil has an advantage of protecting the steel
    from corrosion. Water has the advantage of
    letting the steel corrode a bit. Water can cause
    clay in some naturals to swell. Water can
    also react with minerals and change the micro
    chemistry at the edge (abrasion pH).

    Caution some resin bound man made hones could
    turn to sloppy goo with the wrong solvent or oil.

    Dragons Tongue hone's are slate and slate is
    almost impervious to water. I think this impervious
    to water tips the preference for slate hones
    toward oil.

    I would love it if someone near me was to
    slice one of the old slate chalk black boards into
    3"x14" slabs and sell me one inexpensively.
    Slate was used as roofing tiles back east routinely years ago. It's still used on high end housing. Just contact a specialty roofer and you can get all the slate roof tiles you want.
    No matter how many men you kill you can't kill your successor-Emperor Nero

  11. #10
    aka shooter74743 ScottGoodman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    SE Oklahoma/NE Texas
    Posts
    7,285
    Thanked: 1936
    Blog Entries
    4

    Default

    On my CF I use sewing machine oil (found at hobby lobby in the fabrics section) after Lynn's recommendation and I am experimenting with Kroil. I think the Kroil may be a little light. May try a solution of 50/50 sewing machine oil and Kroil. I recommend the sewing machine oil though...besides, Lynn recommended it & guess what...it worked as usual.
    Southeastern Oklahoma/Northeastern Texas helper. Please don't hesitate to contact me.
    Thank you and God Bless, Scott

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •