This all sounds fine, so you have to figure where the problem lies..

Before you touch another hone I would suggest 100 smooth as you can do Leather laps on the strop, then test shave again after the face rests..

If you still are feeling rough then and only then go to the 12k in 10 lap sets and give it a Tweak and re-test..

It takes time to hunt down an issue, but I promise if you take the time it will teach you a ton about getting the edge you want..

You might end up having to walk the edge back down in grit, you will just have to keep messing with it until it clicks, once it does there will be this light that goes on in yer brain