As Dave said, i love my SWK Scuttle. Its my only scuttle but i didnt want to go thru 3 or 4 of them to find the best. I also have a Captains Choice Bowl. Nice ridges in the bottom and the lip curves in just a touch. This helps to keep the lather in the bowl and not roll over the sides. In a bowl, this detail makes a big difference to me.
The ridges in Petes bowl look very tiny but i bet it would work out nice. Ive read about this type of bowl before and it get great reviews when it comes to making lather.

I dont know about the bowl you posted but i fell the good points in a scuttle are ridges inside and a large capacity to hold water. The more water in holds inside, the longer it will stay warm. Plus you dont want something so big you need to make a place to keep it. Some of them are big!